Wes Welker and the “NFL Total Access” crew break down the Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady debate.

  • Peyton 5 MVPS and took 4 mediocre coaches to the super bowl vs Tom's 5 rings. Both are great.

  • What did I just watch? lol who's better at football?

  • Without cheating manning is better than Brady. Hell Sam Bradford might be better than Brady if he didn't cheat

  • Lil Wes, is still bitter!

  • Manning

  • I thought they were gonna talk bout who he liked to play with more…

  • SysTom Brady

  • Who you got? Welker or Edelman I'm taking Edelman….

  • Manning worse Playoff BUST in NFL history…1 and out 9 times how bad are you when you enter 9 playoff games and lose 9 times??? Manning was great at one thing..Being a DOME QB that got 5 coaches fired

  • Brady made Wes.

  • I feel Wes Welker is one of the very few people who has the most valid opinion on whose better between the 2, since I believe hes the only WR to play for both Tom and Peyton.

  • Is it weird that I still hate Wes Welker ever since you know what?

  • Dumb

  • Hey how bout Edelman vs Welker? Edelman x Edelman x Edelman x Edelman x Edelman x Edelman x go smoke a pole Welker, maybe that one you can get the x

  • Wes Welker is bad luck, 3 SB's with no wins!!! Two with the greatest quarterback ever and greatest coach ever and the other with one of the greatest ever… Dude is bad luck! Side note Julian Edelman is way better and way more clutch!

  • Welker is left half retarded from all those concussions, sucks, hope he doesn't get any nuero things when he is older. The way he talks and acts is night and day from his early days before the head injuries.

  • welker is jealous

  • Welker played with the 2 best QBs in the league during his career and still somehow managed to avoid a ring even after going to like 3 super bowls. Guy must be bad luck.

  • Is he retired

  • Peyton Manning was good but Brady is on another level. Brady has a 10 to 3 all time record vs that papa John pos!

  • Zero debate..Manning isn't even the greatest Colt QB ever/never mind being mentioned with Brady..Other than perhaps Michael Jordan Tom Brady is quite possibly the greatest team sport figure of all time..When you hold every record possible when it counts (7 Super Bowls,5 wins,4 Super Bowl MVP's,orchestrating a 25 point comeback in the Super Bowl halfway through the third quarter ect ect two years prior beating the leauges top defense in the Super Bowl (Seattle) it's become a ridiculous argument…Hell Manning was 1 and out 9 times in the playoffs (horrible)

  • That would be one slow foot race. lol.

  • Which one did you steal 2 super bowls from because you have butter fingers?…. tom

  • No question Brady is Beter

  • TO ALL THE FUCKING BRONCOS FANS THEY ARE JUDGING THEM ON STUFF NON RELATED TO FOOTBALL, SO THIS ISN'T SAYINV WHO IS THE GOAT. SO YOUR BRONCOS FANS GET YOUR FUCKING DUMBASSES AND CCOLTS OFF THIS VIDEO BECAUSE THIS VIDEO DOESN'T DECIDE THE GOAT THEIR TOPICS AREN'T RELATED TO FOOTBALL DUMBASSES

  • Brady

  • No contest

  • Damn ppl why so much hate, everyone has an opinion and thats all it is, an opinion. No one is right or wrong. My opinion (which will get hate too), I never gave either man the edge in this comparison bc football is a team game and there is usually too many variables to say who did better, until I saw 2 things… The 2008 patriot season and then the 2011 Colts season. After watching each respective team WITHOUT their franchise QBs it was more clear to me just how each QB affected their team. The Patriots without Brady in 2008 went 11-5 and became only the 2nd team to win 11 games and miss the playoffs. Then the 2011 Colts without Manning… started the season 0-13 but managed a few wins in the final weeks to go 2-14, good enough for the worst record in the NFL and 1st overall draft choice. Those 2 seasons gave me a much clearer picture of just how important each man was to his team. Now i give the edge to Peyton and i know ppl will bash me and say but what about Super Bowls? To me its silly to compare players by how many SBs they won.. thats for comparing TEAMS not players. Dan Marino in his prime was just as talented as any QB to ever play and he never won a SB bc his team couldn't cut it. Anyway thats my 2 cents and remember its just my opinion

  • Wes Welker should play for Seattle

  • I think these guys are underestimating Peyton speed. Just go look at a Peyton run. Brady just looks like he is still 27 while Peyton looked like he was 45 since his late 20s. Peyton can beat Brady in a foot race

  • welker is hilarious

  • "Can they both lose?" im dying lol

  • Tom brady all the one just cause I never really liked the mannings

  • Who's the best at dropping passes that are in your hands in the Super Bowl?

    Wes Welker [X]

  • Toms been under the same coach and system his whole career guys tend flourish under that kind of stability(look at Joe Montana, Jim Kelly, terry bradshaw) and pats have shown they are just fine without Tom 11-5 2008 season and 3-1 start to 2016 season with the one loss with a injured rookie QB who had maybe two weeks with first team. Jimmy Garapolo by the 2nd or 3rd game was starting to click with the offense scoring in the first three drives against bengals before going down with injury. Colts on the other hand showed without Peyton they would go 2-14. Then they cleaned house and brought pagano and grigson and drafted Andrew Luck. Most GM if they had to choose between Brady and Manning to start a team fresh im pretty sure most would go with Manning. The guy is the greatest QB of all time. Brady just had the greatest career of all time. There is a reason why Peyton has 5 mvps and 10 All-pro nods to Brady's 2 mvps(possibly 3 w/2016) and 3 All-pro(possibly 4 w/2016)

  • Welker has been concussed so many times man look at the mess he became.. Sad like Gay boy Aikman.

  • I am sure Welker would pick Brady considering Manning pretty much ended his career.